As usual
As he was climbing up onto the roof, I told the contractor that I didn’t want to hear that the entire roof was installed incorrectly and that the whole thing would have to be redone.
“The good news,” he shouted down, “Is that your entire roof doesn’t have to be replaced. The bad news is half of it does.”
Price tag: $3700
I told him to only fix the hole then come down.
This is one of the hardest aspects of being a landlord. Problems must be fixed immediately; that I understand. What I didn’t count on was every contractor telling me that the entire “whatever” needs to be replaced because the last moron did it incorrectly.
How do you know?
While I’m waiting to get 2 or 3 different opinions, days have gone by and the tenant still has the same problem. How do you explain that to them? ”Oh the roofer wanted to charge me $3700 but I think he’s full of it so I’m going to wait for a few other guys to come out.”
No.
Tenants only want to hear that you’re fixing their problem.
If I had blindly listened to every single time a contractor told me the entire “whatever” was messed up, I would have paid out an additional $15,000 which I don’t have. And who is to guarantee that the next contractor who shows up doesn’t report back, saying the previous guy did it all wrong.
At the end of the day, the only phrase I utter is “Fix the problem.” If the roof is only leaking in one spot, there’s no sense repairing the entire roof. If the roof does require a complete overhaul, then the temporary fix gives me time to find the $3700.
But for the moment, the leak has stopped.

